squeen
8, 8, I forget what is for
As I continue to try and learn about 5e, I stumbled onto this post which has a nice 2e vs 5e summary of differences.
Here's an excerpt:
Here's an excerpt:
Some Dude said:What's the Evolutionary path of 5E?
5E draws many concepts from 3.X and some from 4.X, but also goes back to Original D&D and AD&D for others. As with 3.X and 4.X, it's a redesign from first principles. It is really, the direct child of 3.X and AD&D 1e
- It keeps 3.X/4.X ascending AC.
- It keeps the fighter being the only one to have lots of attacks of AD&D, but strips most of these from the Barbarian, Paladin and Ranger.
- The list of classes is essentially the "greatest hits" of AD&D through 3.5.
- The races are subdivided into the subraces mentioned in AD&D 1E's Unearthed Arcana.
- It keeps the 3.X and 4.X roll high on 1d20.
- It adds an entirely new roll modifications mechanic (Advantage/Disadvantage) which replaces most of the modifier lists. (Now, modifiers are generally ±2 or ±5, in the few cases they are used at all...).
- Spellcasters gain competence comparable to 4th ed ones - 1st level casters are still glass cannons, but no longer 1 shot artillery. Cantrips being At Will is taken directly from 4th ed, and likewise, cantrips growing at the breakpoints where fighters gain additional attacks.
- Multiclassing is taken largely from the 3E model, but only Proficiency Bonus grows with character level. Spell slots grow with "Caster Level" (which can be from multiple classes)
- Spell Casting and Memorization have changed. The default now works like the 3E sorcerer.
- General Presumption of broad competence - everybody can try most things. They may not succeed, but they can try, and good attributes are highly useful in that regard.
- Array Build - while it appeared in 3.E, it's really taken from 4.0. It's also optional, except for organized play, but the balancing assumes it.
- Higher Hit Die types - Taken from 4E.
- Flat Points Per HD - Taken from a variety of sources (including non-D&D games)... and it is generally better than standard HD rolls, but not by much.
- A climbing proficiency bonus originates in Star Wars Saga Edition... and from there, coopted into 4E and again, but reduced in scale, in 5E.
- The 4E healing surges chand name, but still exist.
Some Other Dude said:So, What's Like AD&D 2E?
Realistically, not that much. Plenty, tho.
Now, note that AD&D 2E in the wild had a few common options in use in most groups:
- Most rolls are made on 1d20.
- Most classes have access to non-combat skills as well as Magic or combat.
- All the 2E core classes exist, except basic wizard: Fighter, Ranger, Paladin, Cleric, Druid, Specialist Wizard, Rogue, Monk. All wizards now make a transition to specialist (arcane tradition) at 2nd level.
- Support for both gridded and Theater of the Mind play
- Plenty of suggestions for character hooks.
- Emphasis on skill driven play. While skills are technically optional, they're part of the default mode of play, just like AD&D 2E Non-Weapon Proficiencies. (Note: unlike AD&D, there's no unskilled penalty, only a bonus for being skilled.)
- Most of your favorite magic items from AD&D 2E will have made the leap.
- Explicit permission for the DM to tinker.
- 4d6 keep best 3 for attributes (Variant I in 1e, Variant V in 2e) - it's back as the default in 5e.
- Options for non-magical healers - it's back, and open to everyone - but it eats a feat.
Last edited: