Why Assassins are awesome!!!

The1True said:
We used the insane Unearthed Arcana dice array well into 3rd Edition. Everyone got sick of it and we went back to 7x3d6 dump the shittiest stat, but everyone was unhappy with their characters (and understandibly suspicious of the one guy with Paladin stats). Like Hemlock said, you can have fun with your mediocre build for 4 or 5 levels, but they're just not going to make it to heroic levels. If you're planning for the long term, you need to build characters with at least one extraordinary prime stat.

god. now I'm remembering the agony of trying to work a fighter character through the percentiles of an 18 Str, 10% at a time with wishes and other junk.
Click to expand...
I dont know man...I really like 'working for it'. By the time we reach 7th or 8th level (usually takes about a year of playing for us), we usually start over and do something else. But crappy stats? well thats what makes magic items worth finding and using. How many tiimes have you kept those extra potions and plan to use them in a "emergency"? Well with bad stats, sometimes any battle can become that emergency and then you are craving for more magic items to survive.
Usually we played with 4d6, drop the lowest die for each stat.
Now we are doing 3d6, then reroll your 3 stats you want with 4d6 and take the best roll.
I really rolled crappy (and my first main character died already)...but we also use (whispers so Squeen can't hear) proficiency/nonproficiency points and the DM allows using 1 of those to increase your stat by 1 if you wish. AND...we roll % for each stat...so your Strength could be 7/45%. Everytime you level, you get 30% points that you add to stats like a thief can with their abilities, so another chance for stats to raise (but again, not by much because we usually go to 7th or 8th level). So we have opportunities to build up our stats which is kinda fun.

Anyways, Im digging the shitty stats if Im honest. Just makes things tougher, which I like. When I was running Vermilion, one player had a fighter with a strength of 13....he got a special ring of regeneration (everytime he hits something, he gains a little hp) and Spear +2 as well as some decent armor and he was really hard to take down.
 
Malrex said:
but we also use (whispers so Squeen can't hear) proficiency/nonproficiency points and the DM allows using 1 of those to increase your stat by 1 if you wish. AND...we roll % for each stat...so your Strength could be 7/45%. Everytime you level, you get 30% points that you add to stats like a thief can with their abilities, so another chance for stats to raise
Click to expand...


Oooo a sort of 2.75e ability boost. I dig it!

I was going to tempt you over to the 3e dark side (because clearly, at this point, your group is just an Ascending AC away from a deadly fall off this slippery slope you're on 😛 ), but then I got this even better idea:

Someone should do a livestream featuring a table full of crusty, grey-haired, dyed in the wool, Old School grognards. Like the kind of dudes that quibble over the differences between B/X and BECMI, and think that all metal died with Dimebag Darrel, maaaybe even a semi-tolerated red ballcap among them.

But they have to play 5e (or, god help me, PF2e).

They don't have to play the 5e WotC adventures, in fact it would be way cooler if they were converting old or indy stuff.
All of them, including the DM, are new to the rules and so SO angry about just everything.
For spice, we throw in someone's kid -Like a blue-haired, poly, non-binary, cat-they- as one of the players!
Zero censorship. We view everything through the lens of ignorance rather than prejudice. Either (all of) these people work their way towards glorious understanding and growth or a spectacular, fiery trainwreck/bloodbath.

I would watch the SHIT out of this.
 
The1True said:
Someone should do a livestream featuring a table full of crusty, grey-haired, dyed in the wool, Old School grognards. Like the kind of dudes that quibble over the differences between B/X and BECMI, and think that all metal died with Dimebag Darrel, maaaybe even a semi-tolerated red ballcap among them.

But they have to play 5e (or, god help me, PF2e).

They don't have to play the 5e WotC adventures, in fact it would be way cooler if they were converting old or indy stuff.
All of them, including the DM, are new to the rules and so SO angry about just everything.
For spice, we throw in someone's kid -Like a blue-haired, poly, non-binary, cat-they- as one of the players!
Zero censorship. We view everything through the lens of ignorance rather than prejudice. Either (all of) these people work their way towards glorious understanding and growth or a spectacular, fiery trainwreck/bloodbath.

I would watch the SHIT out of this.
Click to expand...

I'll talk to my Director...
 
Spent an wonderful evening with a friend I played D&D with in the 70s/80s. @The1True's livestream idea is going to have compete with the podcast title I came up with tonight called "Two Old Guys Misremember the 80's". Which will be comparatively awful, but far closer to reality TV.
 
Last edited:
The1True said:
Like Hemlock said, you can have fun with your mediocre build for 4 or 5 levels, but they're just not going to make it to heroic levels. If you're planning for the long term, you need to build characters with at least one extraordinary prime stat.
Click to expand...

Yes, but AD&D also needs more mechanisms than just aging, magic tomes, and the oddball ioun stone to raise stats, given their importance to long-term campaign play. While I don’t advocate for all of the ho-hum stats-boosting spells and items from 3e, adding some more attribute-bumping strangitude to your world via magical pools and fountains; drugs, herbs and trees/fruits; strange elixirs; and the blessings/curses of gods, demons, and other entities in-between seems required, in particular if you’re playing with level limits for demi-humans.

The1True said:
god. now I'm remembering the agony of trying to work a fighter character through the percentiles of an 18 Str, 10% at a time with wishes and other junk.
Click to expand...

Yeah, that’s crap, and is a total over-reaction to the ludicrous commonality of wishes in OD&D. I ignored that 10 wishes per point rule aeons ago :)

Allan.
 
Hemlock said:
Just for fun, here's four 3d6-in-order arrays for AD&D 2e and what I'd do with them and how long I'd play them:

Str 10 Dex 8 Con 11 Int 13 Wis 9 Cha 16.
Str 7 Dex 5 Con 16 Int 12 Wis 7 Cha 14.
Str 8 Dex 10 Con 6 Int 12 Wis 8 Cha 9.
Str 9 Dex 15 Con 16 Int 11 Wis 4 Cha 13.
Click to expand...

Some of those arrays could get a little better with age and demi-human adjustments, but on the whole they are pretty lame. There’s not even really enough room to adjust stats on a 2:1 basis ;) =)

Allan.
 
Did somebody say "assassins"?

I did up a quick little hand-out for my group, telegraphing an upcoming adversary - if anyone else wants to introduce a new assassin into your campaign world, you're free to use... THE RED SHADOW!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top